★
★
★
★
★
Came here from out of town, and this was some of the best key lime pie I have ever had!! The texture, flavor, crust, EVERYTHING was perfect. They also have a variety of other desserts that looked amazing. They sell a whole key lime pie, but also slices for anyone who just wants one slice. The cashier was also very helpful and recommended some restaurants for us to try in the area. 10/10 recommend this place!
★
★
★
★
★
Was the best Keylime pie Ive ever had. My friend brought one to me in Texas and I wasnt sure what to expect, but it lived up to the reviews I saw online.
She asked what place I wanted to try and picked this one based on multiple articles and reviews..
Everything about the pie was great. The crust, the filling & the topping. Wasnt too tart or sweet..
★
★
★
★
★
The Honeybell Orange cake is incredible and doesn’t have dairy (just eggs). Unique tropical cakes like guava cake. Various scones and breads, I got the Tropical Banana Coconut Bread ($6). Freshly made. Nice, quaint, Old Florida aesthetic. Very kind staff. Known for their orange cake and key lime pie.
★
★
★
★
★
Not a big Sweets guy but wife and kids wanted to stop in this local place and let me tell you, the aroma of the shop immediately made my sweet tooth kick in. The Key Lime pie was DELICIOUS! Also tried my kids cookies and you can tell they are fresh and made with care. The Cherry on Top was they deliver locally, you guys at Flo’s have won us over!
★
★
★
★
★
Best key lime pie I’ve ever had! We happened on it while driving by, and are so happy we stopped. This is worth your while!
★
★
★
★
★
This little pie shop is tucked away but should not be passed by. Went here because I heard they made the best Key Lime pie in the area. They did not disappoint! What a delicious pie with smooth filling and wonderful flavor. I usually prefer a regular pie crust to graham cracker, but I was content with theirs. They use a whipped cream topping, which I prefer over meringue. The pie will set you back $25, but my husband and I agreed it was the best in the area and it brought us back to our trip to Key West many years ago. If Key Lime pie isn’t your thing, they have many other pies flavors available!
★
★
★
★
★
I purchased Key Lime and Lemon Beach pies there for Friendsgiving. They were a huge hit.! They were soft and creamy, light yet decadent. Well worth the trip to South Sarasota. The store itself is bright with a touch of Old Florida charm, all the goodies and yummies colorfully displayed. Very inviting indeed. Friendly knowledgeable staff. After multiple visits, I have never been disappointed. A real treat for myself , family and friends.
★
★
★
★
★
Best Key Lime Pie on the coast!! We've been in FL a week and I made it a mission to try as many Key Lime Pies as possible. This little spot did not disappoint! They sell by the whole pie or the slice (until they are sold out). The crust was flaky & buttery, the custard melts in your mouth and the whipped topping adds a sour punch to keep you coming back for more. My only regret is that I didn't get a second slice ro enjoy again later! Easy access off the main drag into Siesta and open later than most bakeries in the area, this spot is worth the stop!! Highly recommended 👌
★
★
★
★
★
One of the best kept secrets of Sarasota. The owner is amazing and has so much passion for what she does. The cutest cleanest little bakery you will ever see. As soon as you walk in. You are hit with the smell of all the made from scratch sweet treats. If the local restaurants were smart. They would be buying and selling these sweet treats. Thank you for our amazing items. 🎂🍰🥡
★
★
★
★
★
I tasted Flo’s Key Lime pie at a farmers market and it was the best Key lime pie I ever had. We are only in Sarasota for a month and have already purchased 2 pies. My guests agree the pie is delicious.
The shop is a little hard to find but well worth the effort. Highly recommend.